How effective is storytelling in marketing? The evidence

Shoppers queuing at a cheese stall in a covered London food market on a grey morning

Storytelling in marketing is effective when it's specific, believable and shown to the right people more than once, and it's much less effective when it's a vague brand narrative nobody can measure. The best UK evidence says emotional, story-led work tends to build more business over time than purely rational messages, but it's slow, hard to attribute and easy to do badly.

This post is the honest look at the evidence. What the research actually shows, where the claims you see online fall apart, what the numbers look like from the marketers using video, and how to judge for yourself whether a story is earning its place. If you want the how-to, that's in how to use storytelling in marketing, and the reasons it works at all are in why storytelling works in marketing.

What does the research actually say about storytelling?

The most respected UK work on this isn't about stories as such. It's about emotion versus rational persuasion, and stories are the main way emotion gets into advertising. In The Long and the Short of It, published by the IPA in 2013, Les Binet and Peter Field analysed hundreds of campaigns entered into the IPA Effectiveness Awards. Their finding was that campaigns built mainly on emotional appeal tended to produce larger and longer lasting business effects than campaigns built on rational messages, particularly over the long term.

It's worth being precise about what that does and doesn't say. It doesn't say every story sells. It says that brands who make people feel something about them, and keep doing it, build a mental shortcut that makes them easier to choose later. A story is a very good way to build that, because people remember a scene or a person far better than a claim.

There's also a body of academic work on narrative and persuasion showing that people who are absorbed in a story tend to resist counter-arguing as much, which is part of why a good story lands where a sales pitch bounces off. I'd treat the more dramatic claims you'll see repeated, such as "stories are 22 times more memorable than facts", with caution. They get passed around without anyone pointing to a study you can read, and I'd rather give you a smaller claim I can stand behind.

What do marketers who use video say about results?

Video is the format where most business storytelling ends up, so the best large survey data we have is on video. The IPA's Binet and Field analysis of effectiveness case studies found that, in campaigns running three years or more, 43% of emotional campaigns reported very large profit effects against 23% of rational ones. That's a strong signal for stories, and the timescale is worth reading carefully.

More businesses are making video, and a lot of it is made without much thought about what it's for. The marketers who are less happy are, in my experience, often the ones who made something generic and expected it to do the work. A film without a clear story, a clear audience and a plan for where it goes will disappoint, however well it's lit.

When everyone's film looks the same, the average result slips.

I read that dip as good news for anyone willing to do it properly. When everybody's making the same polished, empty film, a specific one stands out more.

Why is the effect of storytelling so hard to measure?

Because a story rarely closes a sale on its own. Somebody sees a short film on Instagram in March, reads a case study in May, gets a recommendation from a colleague in July and fills in your form in September. Your analytics will credit the form fill, or perhaps Google. The film that made them trust you won't show up.

This is the problem every brand storyteller has, and it's why a lot of the claims you'll read are either overblown or quietly unfalsifiable. There are three honest ways around it.

Ask people how they found you

A simple "how did you hear about us?" box, with a free text option, is the cheapest tool in marketing. If people write "I watched your film" or "I saw your video about the shoemakers", you've learned more than from any dashboard.

Look at sales conversations

Do prospects arrive already knowing what you do? Do they quote something from a film back to you? Does the first call start further down the line than it used to? Salespeople notice these things before the data does.

Compare like with like

If you send a film to some quote requests and not others, or add it to the pages that matter most, you can see whether those enquiries convert differently. It's not a laboratory test, but it's better than guessing.

Very large profit effects from campaigns that ran for three years or more
Emotional campaigns43%
Rational campaigns23%

Over three years or more, emotional campaigns were nearly twice as likely as rational ones to report very large profit gains.

Source: IPA, Binet and Field, The Long and the Short of It

When does storytelling work well in marketing?

From what I've seen on shoots, and from the campaigns that tend to get written up, a story does its job when a few conditions are met.

  • It's specific. A named person doing a particular thing in a particular place. "Our passionate team" isn't a story.
  • It's believable. People can tell when they're being sold to. The more it comes from the people involved, in their own words, the more it's trusted.
  • It's relevant to a decision. It deals with a doubt or a question the buyer has, rather than being entertaining for its own sake.
  • It's seen more than once. One viewing rarely sticks. A story that appears as a film, a clip, a case study and a mention in a sales call builds up.
  • It's tied to the real business. The story has to be true of how you actually work, or the first contact with you undoes it.

The big brand examples show the same pattern. John Lewis built a reputation for its Christmas adverts over many years, and they work as a long investment in a feeling about the brand, not as a one-off promotion. Dove's Real Beauty campaign, which began in 2004, stayed on one idea for years and let women tell parts of it. Neither is a template for a small business budget, but the principle scales down: pick a story that's true, tell it consistently, and give it time.

For smaller examples that sit closer to the work we do, see the La Fromagerie film, which tells a business's story through the founder and the people who run it, and the longer discussion of why that film is built the way it is.

When does it not work?

Stories fail in predictable ways, and it's worth knowing them before you spend money.

When it's invented

Fake customer stories, dramatised founder myths and stock-photo "real people" are noticed and punished. The cost isn't just a flop, it's lost trust in everything else you say.

When it's all about you

A film that's only the company talking about its own greatness is an advert. It can work as one, but it's not storytelling and shouldn't be measured as if it were.

When there's nowhere for it to go

I've seen lovely films sit on a YouTube channel with no links, no mention in sales emails and no place on the website. Nobody saw it, so it didn't work. That's a distribution problem, not a story problem. We deal with this in where to use your brand film.

When you expect it to behave like an ad

A direct response ad is judged on clicks this week. A story is judged on whether people choose you over the next year. Judging one by the other's rules is how businesses abandon a good approach after a month.

When the product doesn't back it up

No story can rescue a bad experience. If the story says you're careful and the delivery is late, the story becomes evidence against you.

How effective is it for a small business in particular?

I'd argue it matters more for a small business than for a big one, because you can't outspend anyone. A large brand can buy repetition. A small one has to buy belief, and belief is made of specifics.

A good example of how this plays out is our film for char.gy about their B Corp certification. It's an interview-led film that explains the certification in plain language, and it was cut eleven ways and delivered with an audio described version. It became the most watched thing on their channel, which tells me something I see repeatedly: a clear, honest explanation told by the people involved often outperforms the slicker, more obvious content around it. You can read the details in the char.gy B Corp case study.

That's one client's result, and I wouldn't promise it to anyone else. What I'd say is that when a story is clear, true and re-used across formats, it's reasonable to expect it to outperform a generic brand video, and that's what the evidence from the wider industry also leans towards.

Is the effect different for B2B and consumer brands?

The mechanism is the same, but the timescale isn't. A consumer buying a sofa might decide in a week. A facilities manager choosing a contractor, or a school choosing a supplier, may take months and involve several people who never meet you. In that world the story has to travel without you. Someone watches your film, forwards it to a colleague with a line like "this is the sort of firm I mean", and the colleague arrives at the meeting already half convinced.

That's why I tend to recommend one strong, longer film for B2B work, with a few short pieces around it. The long film is what gets forwarded. The short pieces are how people first meet you. Both come from the same story, which keeps your message consistent no matter who's looking.

How should you judge your own results?

Set the question before you start. Decide what you want the story to change, whether that's the quality of enquiries, the length of sales conversations, the number of people finding you by name or the win rate against competitors. Pick one or two, write down where they are now, and look again after three to six months.

Then separate the story from the delivery. If a film gets watched but doesn't lead anywhere, fix the route. If it doesn't get watched, look at the opening and the title. If it's watched to the end and nobody enquires, the story might be entertaining but not answering a real doubt. Each of those has a different fix.

If you want to see how the structure of a story affects this, which storytelling structure is most effective goes into it, and the complete guide to brand storytelling puts the pieces together.

Documentary-style brand films are built on this idea: real people and real work give you something specific and believable that you can use for a long time. You can see examples on our films page, and if you'd like to talk about whether it would suit your business, get in touch.

Questions people ask

Does storytelling increase sales?

It can, but rarely in a direct, trackable way. Research from the IPA suggests emotional, story-led campaigns tend to build more business over the long term than rational ones. For most companies the effect shows up as better quality enquiries, shorter sales conversations and more people choosing you by name, rather than a spike the day after a post.

How long does it take for storytelling to work?

Plan on three to six months before judging it, and longer for brand effects to build. A single film won't change how people see you overnight. A small set of consistent stories used across your website, social channels and sales conversations will compound over time, and you'll often hear about it from customers before you see it in the data.

Is storytelling better than traditional advertising?

They do different jobs. Direct response ads are good at catching people already looking to buy. Stories are good at making you the business people already trust when they start looking. Most healthy marketing uses both. If you can only afford one, a small business with no brand awareness usually gains more from trust than from clicks.

What is the biggest mistake that makes storytelling ineffective?

Making it generic. A story that could belong to any company in your sector doesn't build any preference for yours. The second most common mistake is making a good film and then not using it, leaving it on a channel nobody visits. Specific stories, told by real people and placed where decisions are made, avoid both.

Got a story worth filming?

We make documentary-style brand films about businesses that are exceptionally good at what they do. The first conversation is free.